For the first time in Tamil Nadu’s political history a Chief Minister oath ceremony pushed "Tamil Thai Vaalthu" to the end. Let that sink in properly.
Not in Delhi. Not in a national parliamentary event. Not in a Prime Minister’s oath ceremony.
In Tamil Nadu.
A state built on language politics. A state where people fought and died protecting linguistic identity. A state that literally has Tamil in its name.
And yet the ceremony began with "Vande Mataram", moved to the National Anthem and only then ended with "Tamil Thai Vaalthu". Tamil was made secondary inside Tamil Nadu itself.
This is not some small procedural change as supporters are trying to portray. This is symbolism. And symbolism matters because politics has always worked through symbols before it works through policy.
The easiest defence now is this.
“It is protocol because the Governor attended.”
But even that argument weakens when the actual guidelines are examined.
The Centre’s recent circular regarding "Vande Mataram" itself was clarified by the Supreme Court as being “purely advisory” and not mandatory. The Court also stated that there are no penal consequences for non compliance. (The Indian Express)
Which means this was still a choice.
And that is exactly why people are questioning it.
Because if Tamil Nadu itself cannot place "Tamil Thai Vaalthu" first during its own Chief Minister oath ceremony then where exactly is Tamil identity supposed to stand with priority.
Why was Tamil pushed behind in Tamil Nadu itself. The usual emotional response from blind supporters is predictable.
“Nation comes first.”
Fine. Then let us speak logically.
This was not the oath taking ceremony of the Prime Minister of India. This was the oath taking ceremony of the Chief Minister of Tamil Nadu. The office itself exists to govern Tamil people within Tamil Nadu. Then why should Tamil identity stand behind everything else in its own state function.
And if the argument is truly about putting the nation first then another uncomfortable question must also be answered.
Why should Vande Mataram become the representation of national identity for everyone when it itself comes from a Sanskritised Bengali cultural framework unfamiliar to huge sections of the country. If unity is truly the argument then where is the equal cultural representation for all states and languages. Why is one region’s symbolism repeatedly presented as “National culture” while others are expected to adjust.
This is exactly how cultural domination begins.
Slowly. Symbolically. Repeatedly.
People are forgetting history too easily.
Tamil Nadu did not resist linguistic imposition for entertainment. The anti Hindi agitations were not dramatic political stunts. Students literally died on the streets because they understood one thing clearly.
Periyar said:
“மொழி அழிந்தால் இனம் அழியும்.”
If a language dies, the people tied to it slowly disappear.
And now look at where we are.
People are already forgetting how to speak proper Tamil. English has become status. Hindi is slowly entering through media commerce and politics. Tamil words are disappearing from everyday conversations. Children are growing up disconnected from their own linguistic roots. Even inside Tamil Nadu speaking fluent Tamil is sometimes treated as less modern.
And now even a Chief Minister oath ceremony cannot place "Tamil Thai Vaalthu" first.
This is not progress. This is dilution.
What makes this even worse is the silence from the same people who scream about Tamil pride. Suddenly everyone becomes quiet when Tamil identity is visibly pushed behind national symbolism inside Tamil Nadu itself. Looks like Tamil pride only matters in social media edits.
No one is speaking against India here. That lazy argument itself shows intellectual dishonesty. Tamil identity and Indian identity can coexist. But coexistence does not mean Tamil must bow its head inside Tamil Nadu.
That is the difference people are refusing to understand.
Our ancestors fought to make sure Tamil would never become secondary in its own land. Today people are voluntarily celebrating the exact thing they once resisted.
This is Shameful.
True
ReplyDelete